Broker Check
When Did You Last Benchmark Your 401(k) Plan? A Recent ERISA Case Offers a $1.2 Million Reminder

When Did You Last Benchmark Your 401(k) Plan? A Recent ERISA Case Offers a $1.2 Million Reminder

October 01, 2026

For business owners and retirement plan sponsors, regularly evaluating plan fees and service providers isn't simply a cost-saving exercise. It's an important part of managing your fiduciary responsibilities.

A recent ERISA case involving Trader Joe’s offers an important reminder for business owners and retirement plan sponsors: retirement plan fees and service providers require ongoing oversight.

In September 2026, a federal judge ruled that Trader Joe’s did not violate ERISA in its use of forfeited retirement plan funds. But the company lost on a separate issue involving recordkeeping fees. The court found that Trader Joe’s failed to take adequate steps to minimize those fees, resulting in approximately $1.2 million in damages and interest.

For plan sponsors, the case highlights a bigger question:

How do you know if your 401(k) plan fees and services are still competitive?

One way to find out is through retirement plan benchmarking.

What Is 401(k) Benchmarking?

401(k) benchmarking compares your retirement plan’s fees, services, investments and plan design with relevant marketplace data and comparable plans.

The goal isn’t simply to find the lowest-cost provider. It’s to determine whether the fees being paid are reasonable for the services and value your plan and participants receive.

ERISA fiduciaries are responsible for prudently selecting and monitoring service providers and evaluating whether plan fees and expenses are reasonable in relation to the services provided.

Benchmarking can help support that process.

What Should Plan Sponsors Benchmark?

A retirement plan benchmarking review can help evaluate several important areas:

Recordkeeping and administrative fees: Are your plan’s costs competitive based on its assets, participant count and complexity?

Investment expenses: Are the costs associated with the investment lineup reasonable and appropriate?

Services and technology: What are you and your employees receiving for the fees being paid?

Plan design: Do features such as eligibility, employer contributions and automatic enrollment still support your workforce and business goals?

Provider performance: Is your provider delivering the service, participant support and resources you expect?

Benchmarking Is About More Than Cost

The cheapest retirement plan isn't necessarily the best retirement plan.

A strong benchmarking process evaluates cost and value together.

It can also identify opportunities that aren't necessarily about changing providers. You may discover that your current arrangement remains competitive, identify fees worth negotiating, uncover unused services or find opportunities to improve your plan design.

Benchmarking doesn't automatically mean issuing an RFP or replacing your provider. It gives you better information to make those decisions.

Is Your 401(k) Plan Still Competitive?

Retirement plans change over time. So do providers, technology, pricing and your workforce.

A plan that was competitive several years ago may not look the same today.

Business owners and plan sponsors should periodically consider:

  • Are our fees reasonable for the services we're receiving?
  • How does our plan compare with similar retirement plans?
  • Are employees receiving the resources and support they need?
  • Are we regularly evaluating our service providers?
  • Are we documenting our fiduciary review process?

If those questions are difficult to answer, it may be time to benchmark your plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is 401(k) benchmarking?

401(k) benchmarking is the process of comparing a retirement plan's fees, services, investments and plan design against relevant marketplace data and comparable plans.

Does ERISA require employers to benchmark their 401(k)?

ERISA requires plan fiduciaries to follow a prudent process when selecting and monitoring service providers and to ensure plan fees are reasonable relative to the services provided. There is not a single federally mandated benchmarking schedule that applies to every retirement plan.

How often should you benchmark a retirement plan?

There is no universal benchmarking interval required under ERISA. Plan sponsors should establish an ongoing monitoring process and consider additional reviews when their plan, provider, pricing, participant population or business changes significantly.

Does benchmarking mean we need to change providers?

No. A benchmark may confirm that your existing provider remains competitive. It can also uncover opportunities to negotiate fees, improve services or plan design, or determine whether a broader provider review makes sense.

When Did You Last Put Your Plan to the Test?

Your retirement plan shouldn't operate on autopilot.

Deschutes Investment Consulting helps business owners and plan sponsors evaluate retirement plan fees, services, investments and plan design through a comprehensive benchmarking process.

Ready to see how your retirement plan measures up?

Request a Retirement Plan Benchmarking Review

Talk with the Deschutes retirement plan team about taking a fresh look at your plan.

This material is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as legal, tax or individualized investment advice. Plan sponsors should consult their legal and other professional advisers regarding their specific fiduciary responsibilities.

Source: Trader Joe's didn't mismanage forfeited funds in retirement plan, US judge rules | Reuters